Is Organic Better? Ask a Fruit Fly

(Consumer news blog) When a middle school student near Dallas, heard her parents arguing about the value of organic foods, she was inspired to create a science fair project to try to resolve the debate. Three years later, her exploration of fruit flies and organic foods has not only raised some provocative questions about the health benefits of organic eating, it has also earned the 16-year-old top honors in a national science competition, publication in a respected scientific journal and university laboratory privileges normally reserved for graduate students. The research, titled “Organically Grown Food Provides Health Benefits to Drosophila melanogaster,” tracked the effects of organic and conventional diets on the health of fruit flies. By nearly every measure, including fertility, stress resistance and longevity, flies that fed on organic bananas and potatoes fared better than those who dined on conventionally raised produce.

 

While the results can’t be directly extrapolated to human health, the research nonetheless paves the way for additional studies on the relative health benefits of organic versus conventionally grown foods. Fruit fly models are often used in research because their short life span allows scientists to evaluate a number of basic biological effects over a relatively brief period of time, and the results provide clues for better understanding disease and biological processes in humans.

 

For her original middle-school science project, the student evaluated the vitamin C content of organic produce compared with conventionally farmed foods. When she found higher concentrations of the vitamin in organic foods, she decided she wanted to take the experiment further and measure the effects of organic eating on overall health. She searched the Internet and decided a fruit fly model would be the best way to conduct her experiment. She e-mailed several professors who maintained fly laboratories asking for assistance. To her surprise, Johannes Bauer, an assistant professor at Southern Methodist University in Dallas, responded to her inquiry. The student worked on the project over the summer, eventually submitting the research to her local science fair competition. The project was named among just 30 finalists in the prestigious 2011 Broadcom Masters national science competition. The professor, following his lab’s policy of publishing all research regardless of outcome, urged the student, then 14, to pursue publication in a scientific journal. The professor and an S.M.U. research associate are listed as co-authors on the research.

Roundup Ready alfalfa not on deck for spring

Roundup Ready alfalfa not on deck for spring

Developer’s focus this year remains on U.S. market

Apr 10, 2013 2:02 PM – 7 comments

TEXT SIZE bigger text smaller text

By: Staff


Forage Genetics International (FGI), the developer of Genuity Roundup Ready alfalfa, won’t be launching its product in Canada for planting this spring.

The Idaho-based forage seed developer’s decision, announced Monday, comes after months of “interest and speculation” about its commercialization plans for the Canadian market, after RR alfalfa returned to the U.S. market last year following a court challenge.

Said interest came to a head Tuesday, with a series of rallies in Ontario and across Canada, organized by the Canadian Biotechnology Action Network (CBAN) and National Farmers Union-Ontario (NFU-O), among others, including calls from the federal opposition New Democrats (NDP) for a moratorium on the RR crop’s release.

CBAN and other opponents contend the release of alfalfa, as an insect-pollinated crop, with glyphosate-tolerant genetics could lead to their unwanted spread in Canada’s conventional and/or organic alfalfa crops, and damage exports to international markets wary of genetically-modified products.

The groups have also contended the release of another Roundup Ready crop could possibly accelerate development of glyphosate resistance in weeds the non-selective herbicide has previously controlled.

Ahead of its rallies Tuesday, Ottawa-based CBAN has said RR alfalfa “could be registered for use in Eastern Canada this April.”

According to Monsanto, which owns the patent on Roundup Ready genetics and licensed the technology to FGI for use in alfalfa, FGI’s “priority and focus for 2013 remains the U.S. market and continued growth in sales and plantings of this beneficial technology to American forage growers.”

That said, FGI “is continuing to evaluate and collect performance data, and gauge grower and industry interest for cultivation of Genuity Roundup Ready alfalfa in Canada,” but “has still not finalized a decision about (its) future commercialization” in the Canadian market.

Monsanto added that a survey last fall of alfalfa growers in Eastern Canada — where the concentration of dairy farms creates a key market for the crop — found “almost half of all farmers surveyed indicated they would be ‘very likely or somewhat likely to try Roundup Ready alfalfa if it was widely available.'”

The federal government granted the glyphosate-tolerant alfalfa full food, feed and environmental approvals in 2005. Health Canada’s Pest Management Regulatory Agency completed its review last spring of Monsanto’s application to allow use of Roundup in Roundup Ready alfalfa.

FGI, Monsanto and other seed companies have run field trials of Roundup Ready alfalfa in Eastern Canada in the past two years — and those trials will continue this year, Monsanto said.

“Extensive” field research by university and government researchers on genetically-modified alfalfa has already gone on for over 15 years with “no impact” on Canadian alfalfa or alfalfa seed exports, the company added.

April 9 2013 – Day of Action to Stop GM Alfalfa

The company Forage Genetics International has applied Monsanto’s genetically modified (GM) herbicide tolerant Roundup Ready technology to alfalfa. Canada approved GM alfalfa for health and environmental release in 2005, but there is one more step before it can be commercially released in Canada: variety registration from the Canadian Food and Inspection Agency. This registration and commercial release could happen as early as this spring!

Alfalfa is used to help produce many of the foods we eat! Alfalfa (commonly harvested as hay) is a high-protein feed for animals like dairy cows, beef cattle, sheep, poultry and pigs. It‘s also used to build nutrients and organic matter in the soil, making it particularly important for organic farming. Farmers agree that GM alfalfa is not needed or wanted but farmers are never consulted before GM crops are introduced.

Alfalfa is a perennial plant that is insect pollinated, therefore, if GM alfalfa is commercially released, GM alfalfa will inevitably contaminate non-GM and organic alfalfa. This GM contamination will threaten the livelihoods of family farmers in Ontario and across Canada. The seed industry says they will focus on Eastern Canada but if GM alfalfa is released, it will only be a matter of time before alfalfa across Canada is contaminated, and sensitive export and organic markets are lost.

More Information:
For information on the Day of Action: www.cban.ca/april9
For more information on GM Alfalfa: www.cban.ca/alfalfa
Other inquiries: Lucy Sharratt, Coordinator, Canadian Biotechnology Action Network 613 241 2267 ext 25 coordinator [at] cban [dot] ca
Ann Slater, NFU-O representative on the Day of Action Coordinating Committee 519-349-2448 aslater [at] quadro [dot] net